Collaborate/J2W: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
J2W
m (tweak) |
(Plainlinks) |
||
| (14 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
'''[[wikipedia:WP:J2W|Journal to wiki publication]]''' is the process of creating or improving Wikipedia, [[wikibooks:Main page|Wikibooks]], [[wikiversity:Main page|Wikiversity]] or similar sites by adapting suitably licensed peer-reviewed research, with author attribution and a link to the original paper. | '''[[wikipedia:WP:J2W|Journal to wiki publication]]''' is the process of creating or improving Wikipedia, [[wikibooks:Main page|Wikibooks]], [[wikiversity:Main page|Wikiversity]] or similar sites by adapting suitably licensed peer-reviewed research, with author attribution and a link to the original paper. | ||
This is made possible by ''open access'' research with Creative Commons licences ([http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ CC-By], [http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/ CC-By-SA] or [http://creativecommons.org/about/cc0 CC0]). | This is made possible by ''open access'' research with Creative Commons licences (<span class="plainlinks">[http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ CC-By], [http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/ CC-By-SA] or [http://creativecommons.org/about/cc0 CC0]).</span> | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
''Not all research is suitable'' for journal-to-wiki publication. As well as being peer-reviewed and suitably licensed, a paper or book chapter needs to be suitably broad in its scope to give an overview of current knowledge. Individual pieces of primary research are not ''usually'' suitable. However, review papers or other works that ''review, synthesise, or summarise | ''Not all research is suitable'' for journal-to-wiki publication. As well as being peer-reviewed and suitably licensed, a paper or book chapter needs to be suitably broad in its scope to give an overview of current knowledge. Individual pieces of primary research are not ''usually'' suitable. However, review papers or other works that ''review, synthesise, or summarise the research'' around a topic are ideal for Wikipedia. | ||
If a paper is more specific than an overview, you can still [[Collaborate/Citation|invite its use as a source]]. | |||
== Adapting a paper for Wikipedia == | == Adapting a paper for Wikipedia == | ||
| Line 16: | Line 18: | ||
* removing subjective or speculative material: Wikipedia's function is descriptive rather than persuasive | * removing subjective or speculative material: Wikipedia's function is descriptive rather than persuasive | ||
* uploading figures to [[Collaborate/Commons|Wikimedia Commons]] from where they can be included in Wikimedia sites | * uploading figures to [[Collaborate/Commons|Wikimedia Commons]] from where they can be included in Wikimedia sites | ||
''If there is already a Wikipedia article on the topic'', don't erase that work, but think about how the old and new content can be combined. Experienced Wikipedians can help you with this. | |||
== Other Wikimedia projects == | == Other Wikimedia projects == | ||
| Line 24: | Line 27: | ||
[[File:Circular Permutation In Proteins.svg|thumb|right|Circular permutation in proteins: a freely-reusable figure used in both a peer-reviewed journal and Wikipedia]] | [[File:Circular Permutation In Proteins.svg|thumb|right|Circular permutation in proteins: a freely-reusable figure used in both a peer-reviewed journal and Wikipedia]] | ||
== Advantages == | == Advantages == | ||
* Bring research to an enormous audience of lay people and academic peers | * Bring research to an enormous audience of lay people and academic peers | ||
* Support Wikimedia's charitable goal of free knowledge for everyone | |||
* Encourage redistribution and translation | * Encourage redistribution and translation | ||
* Get credit and citation of the original published paper | * Get credit and citation of the original published paper | ||
== Examples == | == Examples == | ||
* | *<span class="plainlinks"> ''PLoS Computational Biology'' is publishing a series of [http://topicpages.ploscompbiol.org/wiki/Main_Page Topic Pages] that are developed to be Wikipedia-compatible. These include ''[http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3320104/ Circular Permutation in Proteins]'' (adapted into the Wikipedia article ''[[wikipedia:Circular Permutation in Proteins|Circular Permutation in Proteins]]'') and [http://www.ploscompbiol.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pcbi.1002803 Approximate Bayesian computation] (which [[wikipedia:Approximate Bayesian computation|the Wikipedia article]] is largely drawn from).</span> | ||
* Part of the [[wikibooks:Transportation Economics|Wikibooks textbook on Transportation Economics]] was developed from research published by its authors in the ''Journal of Transport Economics and Policy''. | * Part of the [[wikibooks:Transportation Economics|Wikibooks textbook on Transportation Economics]] was developed from research published by its authors in the ''Journal of Transport Economics and Policy''. | ||
* An [http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pbio.1001384 obituary of the chimpanzee researcher Emil Wolfgang Menzel, Jr.] in '' | *<span class="plainlinks"> An [http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pbio.1001384 obituary of the chimpanzee researcher Emil Wolfgang Menzel, Jr.] in ''PLOS Biology'' was adapted into a [[wikipedia:Emil Wolfgang Menzel, Jr.|Wikipedia article about Menzel]] with a photo shared through Wikimedia Commons. Both the article and photo credit and link back to the original obituary.</span> | ||
* Eurazhdarcho, a newly-discovered species of pterosaur, was announced in [http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0054268 a peer-reviewed paper] in ''PLOS ONE'' in 2013. A lay summary [[wikipedia:Eurazhdarcho|appeared as a Wikipedia article]] ''within hours'' of the paper's publication. ''PLOS ONE'''s free licence allowed the figures and text to be copied, with attribution to the original authors. Wikipedia entries on other newly described species – the frog ''[[wikipedia:Paedophryne amauensis|Paedophryne amauensis]]'' and the "olinguito" (''[[wikipedia:Bassaricyon neblina|Bassaricyon neblina]]'') – even [[outreach:GLAM/Newsletter/January_2012/Contents/Open_Access_report|made]] [[outreach:GLAM/Newsletter/August_2013/Contents/Open_Access_report|it]] to the main pages of multiple language versions of Wikipedia within a day of the original description being published in open-access journals. | |||
* Eurazhdarcho, a newly discovered species of pterosaur, was announced in [http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0054268 a peer-reviewed paper] in '' | *Wikimedia Commons hosts <span class="plainlinks">[http://tools.wmflabs.org/glamtools/glamorous.php?doit=1&category=Open+access+(publishing)&use_globalusage=1&ns0=1&depth=5 well over 20,000]</span> images, videos or audio files that have originally been published in scholarly articles whose license allows such reuse. Video and audio files from suitably licensed articles that are indexed in PubMed Central are imported into Wikimedia Commons [[commons:User:Open Access Media Importer Bot|automatically]]. | ||
== Next steps == | == Next steps == | ||
* Remember that publishing research through a non-open-access publisher, or a publisher with a non-commercial licence, | * Remember that publishing research through a non-open-access publisher, or a publisher with a non-commercial licence, typically prevents journal-to-wiki publication, though details depend on the terms of the agreement with that publisher. | ||
* ''If you are in a Jisc-funded project'', contact the Jisc Wikimedia Ambassador, Martin Poulter, (martin.poulter{{@}}wikimedia.org.uk). | * ''If you are in a Jisc-funded project'', contact the Jisc Wikimedia Ambassador, Martin Poulter, (martin.poulter{{@}}wikimedia.org.uk). | ||
* For other inquiries in the UK, contact Wikimedia UK (info{{@}}wikimedia.org.uk). | * For other inquiries in the UK, contact Wikimedia UK (info{{@}}wikimedia.org.uk). | ||
{{Jisc partnership}} | {{Jisc partnership}} | ||
Latest revision as of 14:47, 23 November 2015
J2W
Journal to wiki publication is the process of creating or improving Wikipedia, Wikibooks, Wikiversity or similar sites by adapting suitably licensed peer-reviewed research, with author attribution and a link to the original paper.
This is made possible by open access research with Creative Commons licences (CC-By, CC-By-SA or CC0).
Not all research is suitable for journal-to-wiki publication. As well as being peer-reviewed and suitably licensed, a paper or book chapter needs to be suitably broad in its scope to give an overview of current knowledge. Individual pieces of primary research are not usually suitable. However, review papers or other works that review, synthesise, or summarise the research around a topic are ideal for Wikipedia.
If a paper is more specific than an overview, you can still invite its use as a source.
Adapting a paper for Wikipedia
The process of converting a paper for Wikipedia involves
- making the language accessible to a lay audience
- explaining technical terms and acronyms on their first appearance, with links to other Wikipedia articles
- adopting the relevant structure, which on Wikipedia means a short lead section summarising the whole article, then sections with headings
- removing subjective or speculative material: Wikipedia's function is descriptive rather than persuasive
- uploading figures to Wikimedia Commons from where they can be included in Wikimedia sites
If there is already a Wikipedia article on the topic, don't erase that work, but think about how the old and new content can be combined. Experienced Wikipedians can help you with this.
Other Wikimedia projects
Wikibooks is a collection of open-content textbooks, allowing a less constrained style of text than Wikipedia. Just like Wikipedia, Wikibooks forbids original research: all content has to based on material that has already been published and peer-reviewed.
Wikiversity is more liberal, allowing original research.
Advantages
- Bring research to an enormous audience of lay people and academic peers
- Support Wikimedia's charitable goal of free knowledge for everyone
- Encourage redistribution and translation
- Get credit and citation of the original published paper
Examples
- PLoS Computational Biology is publishing a series of Topic Pages that are developed to be Wikipedia-compatible. These include Circular Permutation in Proteins (adapted into the Wikipedia article Circular Permutation in Proteins) and Approximate Bayesian computation (which the Wikipedia article is largely drawn from).
- Part of the Wikibooks textbook on Transportation Economics was developed from research published by its authors in the Journal of Transport Economics and Policy.
- An obituary of the chimpanzee researcher Emil Wolfgang Menzel, Jr. in PLOS Biology was adapted into a Wikipedia article about Menzel with a photo shared through Wikimedia Commons. Both the article and photo credit and link back to the original obituary.
- Eurazhdarcho, a newly-discovered species of pterosaur, was announced in a peer-reviewed paper in PLOS ONE in 2013. A lay summary appeared as a Wikipedia article within hours of the paper's publication. PLOS ONE's free licence allowed the figures and text to be copied, with attribution to the original authors. Wikipedia entries on other newly described species – the frog Paedophryne amauensis and the "olinguito" (Bassaricyon neblina) – even made it to the main pages of multiple language versions of Wikipedia within a day of the original description being published in open-access journals.
- Wikimedia Commons hosts well over 20,000 images, videos or audio files that have originally been published in scholarly articles whose license allows such reuse. Video and audio files from suitably licensed articles that are indexed in PubMed Central are imported into Wikimedia Commons automatically.
Next steps
- Remember that publishing research through a non-open-access publisher, or a publisher with a non-commercial licence, typically prevents journal-to-wiki publication, though details depend on the terms of the agreement with that publisher.
- If you are in a Jisc-funded project, contact the Jisc Wikimedia Ambassador, Martin Poulter, (martin.poulter
wikimedia.org.uk). - For other inquiries in the UK, contact Wikimedia UK (infowikimedia.org.uk).
| This page has been created as part of the 2013-14 partnership between Jisc and Wikimedia UK |
 
|