Charity status: Difference between revisions

From Wikimedia UK
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(new draft covering letter)
(try this link instead)
 
(59 intermediate revisions by 19 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
==Covering Letter==


Dear Mr Y....,
Wikimedia UK is a '''[http://www.charitycommission.gov.uk/search-for-a-charity/?txt=1144513 Registered Charity]''' and a '''company limited by guarantee'''. This means that the income and assets of the chapter can only be used to pursue our [[objects]], and that the [[board]] members and members cannot receive any personal benefits over and above the benefits given to other beneficiaries.


;Re: Wiki UK Limited (operating name Wikimedia UK)
When we were formed, obtaining full UK charitable status was identified as one of the key objectives. The advantages of charitable status were identified as:


;Your ref: [insert]
* It adds to our reputation, meaning that people are more likely to donate, join, partner with us and take our views seriously
* We can claim Gift Aid income tax relief
* We can get reduced costs for other services including PayPal and room hire


I refer to your letter dated 17 April 2009 refusing our application to be recognised by you for tax purposes as a charity and to our telephone call on 1 May, during which we discussed the legal situation regarding the “advancement of education” and the ways we can take our case forward.
We drafted our [[constitution]]'s Objects clause having regard to the Charity Commission's advice on the charitable activity called the "Advancement of Education".


The Wikimedia Foundation, the owners of Wikipedia, are recognised as a charity under the law of Florida. Several of our sister “chapters” - including Wikimedia Hong Kong, Wikimedia Germany, Wikimedia Sweden and Wikimedia CH - are also recognised in their jurisdictions as charities. We continue to believe that our activities and our objects are similarly charitable and in our case constitute the charitable advancement of education. However, we accept that we are not aware of any existing English charities whose activities are similar to us, and understand your reluctance to grant tax benefits in the absence of these. Therefore, we would like to ask you to refer our case to the Charity Commission, using the mechanism we discussed on the phone, and ask their view on whether out activities are charitable or not.
An index and links to copies of correspondence relating to our application and the application itself can be found at [[/Correspondence|/Correspondence]].
== Tax authorities application ==


We have set out in our previous letters an outline of our activities and the reasons why we think we are charitable. The charitable object of the “Advancement of Education” is already accepted for libraries, museums and art galleries. We consider that our activities are analogous to these organisations, albeit in a different technological context.
We [[Timeline|first applied]] for charitable status in November 2008 after we were incorporated and the Wikimedia Foundation's [http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Chapters_committee Chapters Committee] had approved our [[constitution]]. As our confirmed annual income was less than £5,000 <ref> See section A3 of [http://www.charitycommission.gov.uk/Library/publications/pdfs/cc5btext.pdf this guidance]</ref>, we were unable to apply direct to the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charity_Commission Charity Commission]. However, we were able to apply to the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMRC UK Tax Authorities (HMRC)], and ask them to [http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/charities/tax/recognition.htm recognise us for tax purposes].


Like Libraries, we make educational material available to the public. Like Art Galleries, we display works of art and works of historical interest for the public to see. And like Museums, our projects are not simply an indiscriminate collection of facts: our projects accept only articles that are considered notable, newsworthy or educational. <ref> Wikipedia, for instance, has the following content policy:
At first, our application was delayed due to a backlog at the HMRC Charities Unit. We asked our MP to intervene to speed the process up, which he did, and we received a [http://www.mail-archive.com/wikimediauk-l@lists.wikimedia.org/msg01080.html final response] in April 2009. The response unfortunately rejected our application, arguing "''The production of an encyclopaedia is not the charitable advancement of education''"


{{quote|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information; merely being true or useful does not automatically make something suitable for inclusion in an encyclopedia. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:NOT)}} </ref>
We obtained informal legal advice and drafted a response addressing the case law raised by HMRC and giving examples of the projects' educational value to demonstrate compliance with Charity Commission [http://www.charity-commission.gov.uk/publicbenefit/pbeduc.asp guidance]. The [[:File:File-HMRC Response Letter.pdf|response]] was sent in June. However, in August they replied reaffirming their decision and refusing to refer the matter.


We enclose two attachments in support of our case:
== Direct application to the Commission ==


# Examples of how the resources that we promote, including the Wikipedia website, are used in structured learning.
In the meantime, we [[Initiatives/Bid|applied]] to the Wikimedia Foundation for a £5,000 grant to help kick start the chapter's programmes. In July we [http://www.mail-archive.com/wikimediauk-l@lists.wikimedia.org/msg01334.html were informed] that this bid had been successful. We therefore immediately started drafting our direct [[Charity Commission application]] which was sent off to the Commission in September 2009.
# A legal analysis comparing our activities to the relevant case law


Thank you once again for the assistance you have given and we look forward to hearing from you in due course.
An initial reply was received from the Commission in April 2010. A firm of solicitors was hired to assist us in our response.  After extensive discussions and some delays, we decided to obtain new specialist legal advice in June 2011, and a written submission of some length was sent to the Charities Commission in late July, addressing the points in their letter and giving additional information.  This response was compiled with the help of our lawyers, WMUK members and the Wikimedia Foundation, revising, updating and expanding the material previously sent, to explain our aims and activities more fully. Our lawyers have also engaged the Commission in a dialogue about our approach before these documents were sent to reaffirm that the Commission were keen to engage with us in a positive dialogue about our charitable status.  The Charities Commission responded with further questions in early September and a very detailed response was sent to them on September 26th.


Yours sincerely,
Charity Status was finally granted in November 2011. Wikimedia UK is now Registered Charity no. 1144513


==== Notes ====


<references/>


Andrew Turvey
[[Category:Charity Status]]
Secretary
Wikimedia UK
Wikimedia UK is the operating name of Wiki UK Limited.
Wiki UK Ltd is a Company Limited by Guarantee registered in England and Wales, Registered No. 6741827.
The Registered Office is at 23 Cartwright Way, Nottingham, NG9 1RL, United Kingdom.
 
== Attachments ==
 
# [[/Use of Wikimedia resources in structured learning]]
# [[/Legal analysis of the advancement of education]]

Latest revision as of 15:56, 29 August 2013

Wikimedia UK is a Registered Charity and a company limited by guarantee. This means that the income and assets of the chapter can only be used to pursue our objects, and that the board members and members cannot receive any personal benefits over and above the benefits given to other beneficiaries.

When we were formed, obtaining full UK charitable status was identified as one of the key objectives. The advantages of charitable status were identified as:

  • It adds to our reputation, meaning that people are more likely to donate, join, partner with us and take our views seriously
  • We can claim Gift Aid income tax relief
  • We can get reduced costs for other services including PayPal and room hire

We drafted our constitution's Objects clause having regard to the Charity Commission's advice on the charitable activity called the "Advancement of Education".

An index and links to copies of correspondence relating to our application and the application itself can be found at /Correspondence.

Tax authorities application

We first applied for charitable status in November 2008 after we were incorporated and the Wikimedia Foundation's Chapters Committee had approved our constitution. As our confirmed annual income was less than £5,000 [1], we were unable to apply direct to the Charity Commission. However, we were able to apply to the UK Tax Authorities (HMRC), and ask them to recognise us for tax purposes.

At first, our application was delayed due to a backlog at the HMRC Charities Unit. We asked our MP to intervene to speed the process up, which he did, and we received a final response in April 2009. The response unfortunately rejected our application, arguing "The production of an encyclopaedia is not the charitable advancement of education"

We obtained informal legal advice and drafted a response addressing the case law raised by HMRC and giving examples of the projects' educational value to demonstrate compliance with Charity Commission guidance. The response was sent in June. However, in August they replied reaffirming their decision and refusing to refer the matter.

Direct application to the Commission

In the meantime, we applied to the Wikimedia Foundation for a £5,000 grant to help kick start the chapter's programmes. In July we were informed that this bid had been successful. We therefore immediately started drafting our direct Charity Commission application which was sent off to the Commission in September 2009.

An initial reply was received from the Commission in April 2010. A firm of solicitors was hired to assist us in our response. After extensive discussions and some delays, we decided to obtain new specialist legal advice in June 2011, and a written submission of some length was sent to the Charities Commission in late July, addressing the points in their letter and giving additional information. This response was compiled with the help of our lawyers, WMUK members and the Wikimedia Foundation, revising, updating and expanding the material previously sent, to explain our aims and activities more fully. Our lawyers have also engaged the Commission in a dialogue about our approach before these documents were sent to reaffirm that the Commission were keen to engage with us in a positive dialogue about our charitable status. The Charities Commission responded with further questions in early September and a very detailed response was sent to them on September 26th.

Charity Status was finally granted in November 2011. Wikimedia UK is now Registered Charity no. 1144513

Notes

  1. See section A3 of this guidance